Skip to main content

Kula Kalvi Thittam (1953) and Relaxation of Child Labour Laws (2015): An Allegorical Reading.

Allegory: This is an account of two political stories, one which unfolded more than five decades ago and another which still remains to do so. The write up tries to employ an allegorical reading, finding similarities between the two and tries to establish certain socio-political commonalities between the two.

An allegory is a narrative strategy whereby while telling a particular story another is alluded to as well. Allegory as a story telling technique has been used throughout history. Some suggest that while Shakespeare was telling the story of Julius Caesar he was allegorising the tale of the then reigning queen- Elizabeth I. Similarly in a piece elsewhere I have argued that through the television series on Mirza Ghalib, Gulzar is allegorising his own past through Ghalib.
Allegory is a tricky but fun way to read a text. One tries to find clues in a story for resemblances to another story. Recently reading a news report on a proposal of the central government, I found certain clues to another story and in the most unlikely place, i.e. a news website, found an allegorical reference. The only difference was no body was consciously making the connection, but it was there. Basically this write up is a fancy way of saying “History repeats itself”.


Story I
On April 8th 2015, it was reported that government is planning to relax laws to allow children below 14 to work in “select family businesses”.These businesses shall not include any hazardous industries but only familial occupations such as helping out the family on the fields, forests and other home based works. Moreover it is also proposed that this work can be carried out only in the spare hours after school, during vacations or whilst attending technical institutions. This, as some officials claim, is being done to promote entrepreneurship among children and also to maintain the “social fabric” of the Indian society “where children learn by participating in work with family elders”. Another logic being given is that this will help the poor families “where children help in subsistence”.
Child rights activists have raised objection to this proposal. According to them child labour is already an underreported crime. By relaxing the laws there are chances that even the hazardous industries will see an increase in the cases of employment of children. Moreover apprehensions are that this relaxation will also negatively impact upon advancements made in expansion of elementary education, specially affecting those made in girls’education.
Apart from these protests there hasn't been a widespread opposition from all sections of the society to the move, with some government supporters even defending the proposal.

Story II
In 1952 C. Rajagopalachari (Rajaji) became the chief minister of Madras state. Appointed by the Congress high command, he represented the brahamin image of the Congress in Tamil Nadu politics. In 1938 during his earlier stint as the chief minister he had introduced compulsory Hindi textbooks in schools which was openly resented and protested against by no less than E.V. Ramaswamy aka Periyar. In 1953 however Rajaji did something which irrevocably solidified his brahiministic legacy and also cost him his leadership in Tamil Nadu politics.
He introduced a scheme of vocational education based on “hereditary calling”[1]. The scheme aimed at imparting the traditional occupation of parents to their children. Once again it was Periyar who fiercely condemned this move and called it out on its conspicuous casteist character. He went on to brand this educational pattern as “Kula Kalvi Thittam” (caste education scheme)[2] and exposed its design of perpetuating the “varnashrama dharma”. Dravida Munetra Kazhagam (DMK) joined in the protest against this scheme and after the tireless crusade of Periyar the scheme was dropped following which Rajaji had to tender his resignation. Following this Kamraj the non-brahamin face of Congress in Madras was appointed the chief minister. Thus this episode proved to be a decisive victory against the brahiministic dominance in Tamil Nadu politics.

Calling a spade a spade
Apart from the insistence on “Hindi”, the two episodes also share the insistence on continuing/learning/participating in, in the familial occupations. Indian social fabric and tradition are famous for their casteist and brahministic designs. The idea of preserving the “social fabric” as suggested by certain officials today, further cements this analogy.
One of the many debilitating effects of caste system is the denial of upward mobility in society due to occupational immobility. In simpler words, a person from lower caste finds it difficult to move up in the social ladder because she is restricted by the occupation ascribed to her caste. For very few who break the caste barriers and improve their socio-economic standing, it involves immense struggle, hardships and continued stigmatisation and discrimination even after achieving success. In such a scenario it becomes even more difficult for those who are trapped by poverty to defy not only their class but also their caste. Thus to say that children should work in familial occupations to help their poor families for subsistence, is not only a statement rife with casteism but also filled with a class bias. Rather than helping out poor families to break the shackles of poverty and let their children attain hindrance free education, this move reinforces their class and caste status. And there are ample proofs that if given the opportunities, these children rather than joining in their ‘traditional’ family occupations can strive for etching their own success in this modern secular world, a section of which deliberately denies them the opportunity to do so.  
That’s why Periyar was alarmed by Rajaji’s scheme and one should be by this proposition as well. But perhaps what Tamil society was in 1953, i.e. equipped with a strong anti-caste, anti-brahamin sentiment, Indian society of today isn't and might never be. The caste agenda has been diluted beyond recognition and the brahaminical authority is not being challenged anymore in mainstream politics. Allegories may be interesting but it is unfortunate that we may keep finding ones such as this, in government proposals and announcements in future as well.


-Sumit 

[1] Kumaradoss, Y. Vincent, “Kamraj Remembered” Economic and Political Weekly, 39.17, 2004, 1666
[2] Ibid

Most Read

उच्च माध्यमिक स्तर पर सामाजिक पाठ्य विषय: महत्व और वस्तुस्थिति।

प्रस्तावना: हिन्दुस्तान के कई शहरों में उच्च माध्यमिक स्तर पर सामाजिक पाठ्य विषयों का विकल्प छात्र-छात्राओं के लिए मौजूद नही है। पर इस स्थिति पर एक समग्र विश्लेषणात्मक शोध की भारी कमी है।विज्ञान, वाणिज्य, कला या अन्य विषय समूह से चुने गए विषय ही निर्धारित करते हैं कि विद्यार्थी आगे जा कर किस क्षेत्र में काम करेगा पर साथ ही यह भी कि उसका सामाजिक और राजनैतिक दृष्टिकोण क्या होगा। इसलिए सामाजिक पाठ्यक्रम को मिलने वाली चुनौतियों के मद्देनज़र उच्च माध्यमिक स्तर पर ध्यान देना अति आवश्यक है।

Ranglok Theatre Festival: Putting Agra On The Indian Theatre Map

Monsoon perhaps inspires more art than any other season; especially performance art. So, what could be better than a festival of theatre to be held right in the midst of this season. Ranglok Sanskritik Sansthan, one of the most prominent theatre groups in the city of Agra, is bringing a four-day theatre festival to the iconic Sursadan auditorium in Agra this month. To be held from 22nd of July till 25th of July, Ranglok Theatre Festival will feature four plays.

हिन्दी एक्शन-फंतासी कॉमिक उपसंस्कृति की यात्रा- इंद्रजाल से लेकर राज कॉमिक्स तक

एक्शन और फंतासी का मिलन एक बेहद शक्तिशाली सांस्कृतिक गठजोड़ है। और अक्सर यह सांस्कृतिक रूप से महत्वपूर्ण गठजोड़ उपभोक्तावाद के लिए भी बहुमूल्य हो जाता है। हैरी पॉर्टर की उपन्यास श्रंखला के लिए पूरे विश्व में दीवानगी को देख लीजिए या फिर अमेरिका की कॉमिक बुक इंडस्ट्री की आपार सफलता को ही, एक्शन और फंतासी की ताकत का अंदाज़ा आपको लग जाएगा। इस गठजोड़ से हमेशा एक उपसंस्कृति का जन्म होता है जिससे उपजे संसार या फिर बहु-संसारों में बच्चे और युवा रोमांच और आनंद तलाशते हैं।
क्योंकि यह उपसंस्कृति भाषा से निर्मित होती है, इसलिए अलग-अलग भाषाएँ और उनका सामाजिक संदर्भ इन उपसंस्कृतियों का स्वरूप निर्धारित करते हैं। हिन्दी भाषा में आधुनिक समय में पहला एक्शन और फंतासी का गठजोड़, हिन्दी साहित्य के पहले उपन्यासों में से एक, देवकी नंदन खतरी द्वारा रचित ‘चंद्रकांता’ में देखा जा सकता है। तिलिस्म और एक्शन से भरपूर इस उपन्यास में कई ऐसे तत्व थे जिन्होंने इस रचनावली को उस समय में ही नहीं, बल्कि आगे के समय में भी लोगों के लिए रोचक और आकर्षक बनाए रखा।
हिन्दी कॉमिक बुक्स का संसार कभी बहुत समृद्ध या वृहद नहीं रहा, पर एक…